Toyota Yaris GR Sport vs. Suzuki Swift – AutoWeek dubbeltest – English subtitles

Toyota Yaris GR Sport vs. Suzuki Swift – AutoWeek dubbeltest – English subtitles


You might remember the Yaris GRMN from a while back,
the ultra-expensive limited edition pocket rocket based on the Yaris, which Gazoo Racing used to launch the GRMN-label. This is some kind
of Light-version of it. The Yaris GR Sport. And it’s more than just some bumpers and stickers. They’ve actually
tweaked the chassis, but they haven’t done anything about the drivetrain. This is still just a hybrid. Not a 1.5 and there won’t be any,
because the Hybrid is the only option available for the GR Sport. A weird choice. And there’s another identity crisis going on over here.
This is a Suzuki Swift with a carbon fibre look-body pack, 17-inch wheels with Michelin PilotSport 4-tires
and an automatic gearbox. An automatic gearbox can be incredibly sporty nowadays,
but this one most certainly isn’t. It’s a 6-speed with torque converter… and it’s nice and smooth, but it will take its time.
Comfortable, but not sporty in any way. So when you’re just driving about, it’s all good. Very comfortable.
But whenever you speed up or go into manual and change gear yourself, it takes a little too long. The gear changes itself are very slow
as well. In manual, when you put your foot down, it just changes down. Not even kickdown. You throttle up and it’ll take control.
It’s good, but it’s just not sporty. And that’s too bad, because the… drivetrain and engine want to go fast. It’s powered by a turbocharged
1.0-litre 3-cylinder which is supposed to produce 112 horsepower and… 160 Nm of torque. That’s 10 Nm less than the manual version,
but we’ve seen quite a lot of these on the rolling road, and they tend to produce more than you bargain for.
Also, even with an automatic gearbox it still weighs less than 1.000 kg. 112 horsepower won’t be enough to burn the place down, but
it’s quite a quick car. It sounds good as well. It’s very easy to go fast, and because it doesn’t weigh a lot
that’s very nice to do. You’ll feel it in the chassis as well. It’s a car which you can throw around without too much consequences,
because the weight is so low. You’ll always catch the car. That makes it incredibly fun to drive. It’s fitted with the optional
17-inch wheels with sticky PilotSport 4-tires, and it means that… you can drive this incredibly quick. However, it doesn’t have the sturdiest
of suspensions. It leans a lot, but it’ll remain grippy. That makes it playful… and agile, and it’s just very communicative. I do have to say,
the suspension isn’t really meant for 17-inch wheels with sticky tires. So the refinement can be a little gone sometimes. As if the
wheel is bouncing around uncontrollably in the wheel arch. Again, the refinement could be improved, but the driving
pleasure in this Swift is really good. Right, the Yaris GR Sport. There’s lots of refinement in here. Why?
They were much more thorough when developing this chassis. Not only does it have sticky tires around its 17-inch wheels, it also has
bigger shocks, a bigger anti-roll bars, so there’s more work done to it. You’ll notice that. I wouldn’t call this more comfortable, because it’s still
pretty sturdy, but the wheel movements feel more stable. The wheels aren’t bouncing around and you aren’t thrown through
the car. That means that when you steer, it doesn’t roll as much… and thus feels more precise. It’s easier for you to detect the limits
of this car. Also, it’s incredibly grippy. You can really throw it around… corners at incredible speeds. I mean, it’s still a Yaris.
That’s very good. However, when you get to the drivetrain, and it all falls apart. You hand in some comfort for more sharpness,
but if you want to use that sharpness, you need speed. And because it’s a hybrid, you have to keep your foot hard down,
which means the engine will make a lot of noise. But it won’t go a lot quicker at all. So you actually don’t have the
power to go utilize the chassis capacity. It sounds very stressed, it’s slow… Also, the pedals feel very spongy,
so you don’t really know how far you have to press it. There’s nothing wrong with the hybrid drivetrain because it’s very economical
and it feels very smooth, but combined with a sporty chassis? It really doesn’t help. It’s actively working against the chassis,
which means it’s just not fun to drive. At all. So, a clear victory for the Suzuki Swift? Not immediately. It certainly
is the most fun to drive. The chassis and drivetrain have a better… balance than the Yaris, but the way it stands there with automatic
gearbox, body-pack and 17-inch wheels, it’s €26.000. About as much as this Yaris, but this feels more like a car costing €26.000.
Both in the interior as underneath the skin. Also, the Yaris is more spacious. Despite all of that, the Swift wins. But not this one,
the manual one. Because that’ll save you €2.500. However, if you take away only €1.000, you can buy yourself
a Swift Sport with a manual gearbox. Now that’s a fun car to drive.

About the Author: Michael Flood

19 Comments

  1. De GR Sport is waardeloos. De Yaris GRMN (de snelste kleine auto op dit moment) is wel vet. Met 212PK is dat ding echt snel! Deze GR-Sport daaraantegen…pfffff, wat een gedrocht!

  2. Swift Sport is het meeste fun in deze klasse. Vermogen is goed en weegt geen drol. Deze versie zonder 1.4 turbo is het net niet. Maar ja niet iedereen rijdt als een hooligan.

  3. Het is je inderdaad wel goed gelukt om twee identiteitscrises bij elkaar te zetten, die nog idioot duur zijn ook. Ik zou ze beide niet kopen, die Swift Sport is inderdaad een goede conclusie. Wat zou de doelgroep van deze auto's zijn?

    De Yaris is een ontzettend goede en vooral comfortabele auto, de HSD hybride-aandrijflijn van Toyota is niet sportief en gaat dat ook niet worden. Ik rijd een C-HR met de 1.8 HSD, daar geldt precies hetzelfde voor. De auto kan hard de bocht om, maar nodigt totaal niet uit om dat te doen. Hij kan het echt wel, als je het gewoon doet (50 over een dorpsrotonde, alle grip van de wereld). Houd rekening met 1-2 seconden vertraging bij volgas voordat er iets gebeurt (ook bij gewoon inhalen van 80-120). Bij normaal rijden is dat helemaal niet erg, maar sportief, echt niet. Diezelfde C-HR rijdt wel 1 op 20 als je rustig aan doet, en 1 op 18 als je ook 130 op de snelweg rijdt. Daar is het geheel ontzettend goed in. Deze Yaris rijdt nog veel zuiniger, 1 op 23 en beter is prima haalbaar.

  4. Iets klopt hier totaal niet een Yaris Sport. Toyota ouwbollige wagens en dan in sportuitvoering met een prijs waar je van achterover slaat. Totaal misplaatste auto.

  5. Deze auto's worden ontworpen en gemaakt in een land waar ze aan de verkeerde kant van de weg rijden. En dat is niet het enige wat ze fout doen !!

  6. Wie gaan deze 2 gebakjes kopen? Voor hetzelfde geld koop je een zeer sportief en luxe uitgevoerde Clio R.S line of 208 GT line die gegarandeerd bakken meer rijplezier bieden dan deze 2 bejaarden mobielen.

  7. say what 26K!?! ze zijn echt knetter gek. 8k bij leggen en heb je een dikke mazda 3 sedan GTM uitvoering met skyactive X motor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *